Dividend Recap Activity Reaches All-Time High

Jun 2021

What drives this activity and what risks do boards face?

As the initial economic fallout from COVID-19 dissipated towards the end of 2020, the drought of dividend recaps in 1H20 was followed by a flood of large, mostly high quality and low COVID-19 impacted borrowers into the debt markets. The pace has quickened in 2021, and year-to-date the volume of dividend recaps has set records—and we expect that trend to continue.

Summary

 

How has the pandemic impacted dividend recap volume and pricing?

Sponsored borrowers have aggressively ramped up dividend recap activity with overall pricing remaining flat on average though “barbell” in terms of industry sector with IT borrowers taking advantage of COVID-19 tailwinds.

Sources: S&P LCD Comps and Refinitiv
(1) Pre-COVID represents 1/1/2019 – 3/13/2020
(2) Post-COVID represents 3/14/2020 – 3/3/2021

In the current market, many companies are experiencing or have experienced a “COVID-19 bump,” which is driving higher EBITDA levels. Buyers, however, remain skeptical about the sustainability of the increased performance. Differing views of this “new normal” EBITDA are creating a disconnect between buyers and sellers, causing some owners and boards to move forward with a dividend recapitalization now and a sale later, when full value can be realized for the increased performance of the business.

REASONS TO CONSIDER A DIVIDEND RECAPITALIZATION

Sponsored borrowers have aggressively ramped up dividend recap activity with overall pricing remaining flat on average though “barbell” in terms of industry sector with IT borrowers taking advantage of COVID-19 tailwinds.

As the number of dividend recaps in 2021 continue to increase at a rapid clip, the reasons sponsors may pursue a dividend recap include:

Current leverage level is below “market,” including situations where a sponsor over-equitized the initial purchase.


Company is generating strong free cash flow with the ability to service a higher level of debt (focus on fixed charge coverage).


Owners would benefit from a near-term return of capital driven by potential tax law changes or fund dynamics.


Allows owners to take “chips off the table” and de-risk fund returns today without giving up the upside expected in a future exit through M&A.


Parallel path process as a potential alternative to a full sale in the event the board/management believes appropriate value has not be achieved through sale process.

CHARACTERISTICS OF GOOD POTENTIAL BORROWERS

Lincoln identified the following four traits that lenders look for in borrowers pursuing a dividend recap:

Steady historical revenue with good visibility – ideally demonstrated by some combination of multi-year contracts, sole-source relationships, recurring “sticky” customers, and/or high barriers to entry or competition.


Favorable industry dynamics – underlying market growth and low cyclicality.


Relative stability in cost structure and asset base – borrower not undergoing major operational changes or embarking on large capex projects.


Private equity-backed or other institutional ownership is preferred. Non-sponsored companies will likely have access to lower levels of leverage, all else being equal.

USE OF SOLVENCY OPINIONS TO MITIGATE RISKS INHERENT IN A DIVIDEND TRANSACTION

In the event the borrower becomes distressed or insolvent in the future, creditors may allege the dividend was a fraudulent conveyance.

Directors:
Could face significant personal liability


Potential “Unwinding”:
Shareholders could be forced to return dividend and/or settle litigation


Secured Lenders:
Secured claims may need to settle for significant discounts, despite previously negotiated collateral

CONSIDERATIONS AND RISK MITIGANTS FOR BOARDS

To lessen the risk of future fraudulent conveyance claims and minimize personal liability, board members should:

Investigate financial flexibility of borrower and its ability to achieve strategic goals with the increased leverage.


Understand the legal requirements to pay a dividend (i.e. surplus under DGCL §154).


Obtain a Solvency Opinion from a qualified investment bank. Lincoln’s clients obtain solvency opinions for many reasons, but the personal liability that members of the Board of Directors could face is often the leading one.

  • Directors can rely on the opinions of experts in discharging duty of care.
  • Line of defense for shareholders and directors in a fraudulent conveyance claim.
  • Reduces risk and potential liability in a bankruptcy.

The Lincoln Difference

Lincoln’s Valuations & Opinions Group, which performs 2,200 valuations per quarter as part of an investment bank with highly active M&A and Capital Advisory Groups, brings real world experience and deep industry expertise to every one of its fairness and solvency opinions engagements. In addition, the portfolio valuation work performed on behalf of over 100 alternate asset managers has earned Lincoln a sterling reputation and credibility within the institutional LP community.

Contributors

Meet Professionals with Complementary Expertise

Related Perspectives

Alternative Credit Investor | Covenant Breaches Decline for Third Quarter in a Row

Originally posted by Alternative Credit Investor on February 22, 2024. According to the Lincoln International Valuations & Opinions Group proprietary data, lenders and borrowers are proactively addressing potential defaults and… Read More

Media Momentum: Q4 2023 Lincoln Private Market Index

February 2024 Our Valuations & Opinions Group recently discussed findings from the Q4 2023 Lincoln Private Market Index with several publications. Bloomberg Bloomberg TV CFO Pitchbook Private Equity Professional The Wall Street… Read More

Bloomberg TV | Banks and Private Credit Cash Competition

Originally aired on Bloomberg on February 13, 2024. The Q4 2023 Lincoln Private Market Index highlights that competition on pricing and terms increased in the direct lending market as the… Read More

Q4 2023 Lincoln Senior Debt Index

Lincoln International is pleased to release the quarterly Lincoln Senior Debt Index (LSDI). The LSDI represents years of research and analysis of data and was developed by professionals from Lincoln’s… Read More