White concrete frames rising in steps against a clear blue sky, evoking the tiers of the CLO capital structure

NAIC CLO Capital Changes: Implications for CLO Debt, Capital Efficiency and Relative Value

How revised risk-based capital requirements could reshape the relative attractiveness of broadly syndicated and middle market CLO debt.

U.S. insurance companies have historically represented an important source of demand for rated CLO debt, particularly across investment-grade tranches. The attractiveness of these securities reflects not only their underlying credit and structural characteristics but also the regulatory capital treatment associated with their ratings.

Beginning with year-end 2026 reporting, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is implementing revised risk-based capital (RBC) treatment for CLO investments held by life insurers. Rather than relying exclusively on the traditional bond factors associated with an assigned NAIC designation, the revised framework introduces CLO-specific factors intended to better reflect the risk characteristics of the underlying securitization structure.

Summary

The impact varies meaningfully across the CLO capital structure. Higher-rated CLO debt generally benefits from lower C-1 factors under the revised framework, while lower-rated mezzanine debt can experience materially higher capital requirements. The divergence becomes particularly pronounced further down the capital structure, where revised factors can represent several multiples of the historical bond factors.

As a result, the implications of the revised framework extend beyond changes to individual capital factors, introducing new considerations for how insurance investors evaluate CLO debt across ratings and underlying collateral types. Differences in available spread compensation between broadly syndicated loan (BSL) and middle market (MM) CLOs, when evaluated alongside revised capital requirements, may meaningfully influence relative-value assessments and the efficiency of capital deployment. At the same time, recent trends toward greater tranche segmentation provide further context on how CLO capital structures are evolving alongside the changing regulatory landscape.

Understanding the NAIC CLO Changes

The revised CLO-specific factors are the culmination of a multi-year effort by the NAIC to better align regulatory capital requirements for structured securities with their underlying economic risk. In developing the new framework, the American Academy of Actuaries evaluated the historical performance and structural characteristics of U.S. CLOs and developed modeled C-1 factors across the NAIC designation spectrum. These modeled factors ultimately formed the basis of the CLO-specific schedule adopted for year-end 2026 reporting.

Importantly, the underlying actuarial analysis focused on U.S. BSL CLOs. MM CLOs were not directly included in the modeled population, reflecting, among other considerations, differences in the availability of credit ratings for the underlying collateral. Despite this distinction, the adopted framework generally applies the same base CLO-specific C-1 factors to similarly designated BSL and MM CLO debt, while maintaining separate treatment for certain thin BSL tranches.

Figure 1: Historical vs. Revised CLO C-1 Factors by Rating

Historical bond factors and revised CLO factors by rating and NAIC designation, with the change in each
Rating NAIC Designation Historical Bond Factor Revised CLO Factor Change
AAA 1.A 0.158% 0.036% (0.122%)
AA+ 1.B 0.271% 0.048% (0.223%)
AA 1.C 0.419% 0.048% (0.371%)
AA- 1.D 0.523% 0.048% (0.475%)
A+ 1.E 0.657% 0.168% (0.489%)
A 1.F 0.816% 0.168% (0.648%)
A- 1.G 1.016% 0.966% (0.050%)
BBB+ 2.A 1.261% 2.175% +0.914%
BBB 2.B 1.523% 3.245% +1.722%
BBB- 2.C 2.168% 3.281% +1.113%
BB+ 3.A 3.151% 15.132% +11.981%
BB 3.B 4.537% 25.156% +20.619%
BB- 3.C 6.017% 27.981% +21.964%

Source: NAIC

The revised factors introduce significant differentiation across the CLO capital structure. For example, the C-1 factor for AAA-rated debt declines from 0.158% to 0.036%, while the factor for BB-rated debt increases from 4.537% to 25.156%, more than five times its historical level. The impact is also uneven within investment-grade ratings, with A- and higher-rated tranches generally benefiting from lower factors, while BBB-rated debt faces higher requirements. As a result, the regulatory capital implications vary considerably depending on a tranche’s specific rating and position within the capital structure.

In addition to the revised base C-1 factors, the framework introduces an incremental capital surcharge for certain thin tranches of BSL CLOs. BSL tranches designated NAIC 2.C (approximately BBB-) or below with a current thickness of 4% or less are subject to an additional 11.77 percentage-point surcharge on top of the applicable pre-tax RBC factor. Tranche thickness is measured as the difference between a tranche’s attachment and detachment points based on the most recent available trustee report.

The thin-tranche surcharge applies specifically to BSL CLOs and does not extend to MM CLOs under the adopted framework. This distinction introduces an additional consideration when comparing similarly rated debt across the two markets, particularly for lower-rated tranches where structural characteristics may meaningfully influence regulatory capital requirements.

CLO Spread Dynamics: BSL vs MM CLOs

MM CLO debt has historically offered a spread premium to similarly rated BSL CLO debt, although the magnitude of that premium has varied meaningfully over time. Since the beginning of 2025, the MM-to-BSL spread basis has generally narrowed across A, BBB and BB-rated debt during more constructive periods.

Figure 2: BSL and MM CLO Spreads by Rating

Spreads in basis points, monthly, January 2025 to October 2026

Single-A Spreads: BSL vs. MM

BBB Spreads: BSL vs. MM

BB Spreads: BSL vs. MM

MM CLO Spread Premium to BSL CLOs by Rating

Source: Lincoln Lens

The compression has not been linear. Periods of broader market uncertainty have generally coincided with renewed basis widening, including tariff-related volatility in April 2025 and geopolitical volatility surrounding Iran in early 2026. The effect has also tended to be more pronounced farther down the capital structure, where changes in risk appetite and liquidity can produce greater spread dispersion.

Taken together, these movements illustrate how liquidity, collateral characteristics and investor risk appetite can influence the MM spread premium even within comparable rating categories.

Assessing Capital Efficiency: Spread Relative to RBC Requirements

While nominal spreads provide a useful starting point for evaluating relative value across CLO debt, the revised NAIC framework introduces an additional consideration for insurance investors: the amount of spread compensation available relative to the regulatory capital associated with an investment. To illustrate this relationship, Lincoln evaluates the ratio of CLO spreads to their applicable C-1 factors under both the historical bond framework and the revised CLO-specific framework. This measure provides a simplified indication of capital efficiency, expressing annualized spread compensation relative to the applicable capital factor rather than a comprehensive measure of return on statutory capital.

Figure 3: CLO Spread-to-Capital Factor Ratios Under Historical and Revised RBC Treatment

Spread-to-Capital Factor Ratio

BSL CLOs

MM CLOs

Notes: Based on recent U.S. new-issue BSL and MM CLO spreads by rating category. C-1 factors reflect NAIC designations shown in Figure 1 of this article (A = NAIC 1.F, BBB = NAIC 2.B, BB = NAIC 3.B). Spread-to-capital ratio calculated as annualized spread divided by applicable C-1 factor. Ratios exclude any applicable BSL thin-tranche surcharge.

Source: Lincoln Lens, NAIC

The comparison highlights the uneven impact of the revised capital framework across the CLO capital structure. Higher-rated debt, particularly single-A tranches, experience a substantial improvement in spread-to-capital ratios as the applicable C-1 factors decline. Conversely, BBB and BB-rated tranches exhibit a deterioration in capital efficiency as higher revised factors more than offset their additional nominal spread compensation. While MM CLO debt generally offers wider spreads than similarly rated BSL CLO debt, the relative attractiveness of that premium depends increasingly on the regulatory capital associated with each tranche. These differences underscore the importance of evaluating CLO debt on both a nominal spread and capital-efficiency basis, rather than relying on headline yield alone.

Post-Announcement CLO Issuance and Structural Trends

Beyond the implications for relative value and capital efficiency, recent CLO issuance has exhibited several notable structural trends following the NAIC’s announcement on June 23, 2026. For example, there has been a notable increase in junior single-A tranches, which benefit from more favorable capital treatment under the revised framework. Among U.S. new-issue CLOs, the proportion of transactions issuing multiple single-A-rated tranches increased from approximately 14% prior to the announcement to 48% afterward, while the prevalence of multiple BBB-rated tranches rose from 71% to 81%. Despite this increased segmentation, the proportion of transactions issuing at least one BBB or BB tranche remained largely unchanged, suggesting that the observed shift has been concentrated in how the rated debt stack is structured rather than whether lower-rated debt is issued at all.

Average tranche thicknesses have also declined modestly, with aggregate BBB thickness decreasing from 6.73% to 6.24% of the capital structure and BB thickness declining from 3.24% to 2.99%. While these developments coincide with the introduction of the revised NAIC capital framework, they may also reflect broader market conditions, investor preferences and evolving structuring practices. Taken together, these trends highlight a shift toward greater segmentation of the CLO capital structure.

Looking Ahead

As insurers begin incorporating the revised CLO-specific C-1 factors into year-end 2026 capital planning, the implications for investor demand, relative pricing and issuance structures will become increasingly relevant. The uneven impact across ratings, combined with the additional treatment of certain thin BSL tranches, introduces new considerations for how insurers allocate capital across the CLO market.

While the ultimate market response remains uncertain, the revised framework reinforces the importance of evaluating CLO debt through both its available spread compensation and associated regulatory capital requirements. These considerations will continue to interact with underlying credit fundamentals, liquidity and structural protections in determining relative value across BSL and MM CLO debt.

Contributors

Related Perspectives